Monday, June 30, 2008

Anonymice



A few years back, Amazon discovered that authors and friends of authors (all anonymous) were giving a 5-star ratings to their own books! Who would have thought? Why would they do that? The shock of it all!

The technology permits anonymous and spontaneous publication of people's comments and we expect the majority of those comments will be honest, civil, and legal. Yet the online environment is infested with libelous demagogues. We must no longer allow the online media to be used for anonymous sniping and personal attacks. There's too many opportunists out there looking for mischief and mayhem.

In our town the anonymity was taken to an art form: anonymous comments on anonymous blogs! Before the 2007 Election, an anonymous blog aimed “to exist throughout the 2007 election season for people in our town to express themselves anonymously. No names - Everyone will remain anonymous.”

Everyone remained anonymous for about 48 seconds. It took me that long to identify Kathy Kuthy as the author of the “non-partisan” blog. Zali Win – the Town of Rochester Democratic Committee Chairman – sent this e-mail to everybody and his brother announcing the birth of his brainchild:

New Blog Established for Town of Rochester Community
We don’t know who established it, but its an interesting way to express your ideas. http://tor2007.blogspot.com

He forgot to add “0 pounds, 0 ounces, 0 inches.”

On May 12, 2008 another anonymous blog popped up, kind of DOA. Zali Win welcomed it too. Of course he did. Under the cover of anonymity, people’s ability to discuss their differences in a rational and civil fashion begins to erode, and they become much more easily manipulated.

Anonymity doesn't build community, it harms it.

The online insurrection is here to stay...



In the digital age, never get in a dispute with someone with access to a computer. Because if he is aggrieved enough, and righteous enough, and persistent enough, and connected enough, he can bury you. Or at least make your life miserable for a long, long time. He doesn't need to have a chain of newspapers, all he needs to have, basically, are fingers and rage...

For people with anger issues, the internet is a cathartic godsend and/or lethal weapon. You know the type — people who might accept the ordinary indignities of life with reasonable equanimity but become suddenly radicalized when lied to, cheated, bullied or otherwise personally abused...

Some of us — no matter how generally sweet-natured and generous, no matter how friendly and thoughtful, no matter how empathetic and transcendently kind — are simply not to be screwed with. Because when we are wronged, we will go to rather extreme lengths to be righted...


(Selected quotes from Comcast must die! by Bob Garfield
Advertising Age, November 19, 2007)